Hope for Type I diabetics

Living Cells Technology have announced the beginning of phase II trials of their product for helping Type I diabetics (they call it DIABECELL).  The idea behind the technology is to inject cells (called islet cells – normally present in the pancreas) that can sense glucose levels and release insulin.  LCT has managed to isolate these cells from pigs and encapsulate them in a way that the body’s immune system will not react to them – no anti-rejection drugs necessary.  Being xeno-transplant it has gone through quite a process even to get to the stage of Phase I trials.

This is pretty cool and I sure hope it all works out.  A Phase I/IIa (safety trials and first stage efficacy trial aimed to find an optimal dose) has been conducted at Middlemore hospital in New Zealand and another is underway in Argentina.  A press release in September announced the success of the Middlemore trial:

The New Zealand dose-finding trial was led by Dr John Baker at Middlemore Hospital in Auckland and saw 14 patients treated with a single implant of DIABECELL at doses of 5,000, 10,000, 15,000 and 20,000 IEQ/kg (islet equivalents per kilogram of body weight). The trial demonstrated that DIABECELL is a safe and effective treatment which results in: 

  • a statistically significant reduction in unaware hypoglycaemic events at doses of 5,000 and 10,000 IEQ/Kga
  • trend to reduction in HbA1c
  • improvement in patient-reported quality of life 

Note – HbA1c is just a form of haemoglobin (from the blood) proportional to the blood plasma glucose concentration.

Positive preliminary results from the 9 person Argentina based Phase I/IIb trial were announced.  The difference from the NZ trial is that two doses were given 12 weeks apart.  Followup has not been complete.

While this is all good news, I see no indication that the research has been peer reviewed (nothing in the Press release and I looked on PubMed as well).

The announcement this week is of a phase IIb trial of 20 patients with a dose of 10 IEQ/kg.  The announcement mentioned the trial will be in Argentina with 20 patients.  This is a little different from a September press release which mentioned 15 patients. The hope to metamorphosise the Phase IIb trial into a Phase III trial with an additional 10 patients from NZ.  A Phase III trial is to confirm effectiveness and monitor side effects – it is intended as the final step before regulatory approval.

In the press release the CEO announced.

“We remain on track to meet our goal of completing clinical trials of DIABECELL by 2015 and having a product commercially available by 2016.”

When I read this I thought “gulp – that is pretty positive given trials have yet to be completed.”  I gulped twice when I realized the trials to date have yet to be peer reviewed (although some results are public).  My third “gulp” is that these trials are all in small numbers – especially the planned Phase III trial.  That is not to say that I have any suspicions about the results or the technology, merely I worry about the juxtaposition of “completing clinical trials” and “commercially available” without the explicit interim statement of “and if the product is shown to be safe and effective.”

Got something to say? Don't be shy

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s